The Confusion of Recent Days
As we get to the end of another interesting week of social distancing, have you noticed how confusing everything is? I am getting my daily dose of exercise by creating home work-outs early in the morning and then taking a long walk most evenings. It has been nice to see many Claremont parents out and about, even if it’s just a quick wave as we both jog by. As a Coogee local, I have never seen the place so busy. The walking track, the beach promenade, and Coogee Oval are a flurry of activity. It’s so nice to experience a sense of community with so many people out and about. Most people seem to be respecting social distancing recommendations - but aren’t we meant to be in a crisis? It’s confusing.
As I take my walks, I am reminded of the beauty of our city and coastline. I have enjoyed some spectacular sunsets this week. Once again I have been blown away by expansive views from the cliffs and Dolphin Point Headland that I would often take for granted. The ocean and sky have never been clearer. The beach is beautiful. I am reminded that I live in a place that is a top tourist destination and I understand why thousands of people from around the world come to visit Coogee - it’s breathtaking. I am also reminded that while I am enjoying all of this, people are suffering with loss of employment and for some so sadly, the loss of loved ones. We are in a crisis - it’s confusing.
For my family, we have ‘mostly’ enjoyed spending more time together. We’ve had a lovely time watching a good number of Netflix series together, playing cards (Canasta) and board games. I have done so much cooking and we have reclaimed (again mostly) good habits of eating together as a family around the table. I can’t believe how much food we seem to go through and we are spending more money than ever at the supermarket - not panic buying for stocking up, rather we just seem to eat a lot more. With these lovely family moments, I need to reassure you that we still have plenty of fusses, arguments (especially over cleaning up after yourself), the kids annoy each other (I’m sure that I annoy them), and at times my wife and I lose our patience with each other. I am thankful for the joys of family life, and sometimes this feels like an extended summer holiday. But it’s confusing. I am reminded that we are in a crisis.
At a personal level, I am getting confused what day it is. I feel like I am doing all of these lovely things at home but my work, as I am sure you would appreciate, has been very demanding, and stressful. This week’s round of latest COVID-19 related announcements have been confusing too. As an educator I find much of the news and commentary confusing. If you too are finding things confusing and contradictory, I want to reassure you that it’s not just you. To be honest I think that much of the news we are getting now is unhelpful rubbish.
It’s certainly confusing when:
- We are told to socially distance but the Bunnings checkout area is congested with dozens of people.
- We can’t have more than 5 people at a wedding but the Prime Minister’s Press conference has a dozen people sitting side by side.
- Parents are told that you should keep your child at home, but schools are open “for all”.
- We should be working remotely from home and we cannot have visitors in our homes, yet teachers and other essential workers should be at work.
- We are told that we are flattening the curve (which is great news) but also told that there are ‘hidden dangers’ with a flattened curve.
- We are told that the crisis is easing but we should be prepared for a spike, especially here in the Eastern Suburbs.
- The NRL has a restart date, but not the AFL - that’s not fair!
It’s doubly confusing when the so-called experts disagree with each other, and when the Prime Minister appears to say something contrary to the Premier, and when the ‘Herald’ reports on the same issue opposite to the ‘Telegraph’.
I am attempting to segue to an important point here; that I expect that you too may be confused by this week’s many media conversations regarding what is best for the education and schooling of your children. It is now confusing when we are told children should come to school one day a week for ‘face-to-face’ teaching because this is better than online learning. Face to face is certainly better in regards to the learning for my 2 nieces (aged 10 and 12) whose schools are giving them the equivalent of only 15 minutes of online school work each day.
So what is best during this crisis when we are balancing not only student educational outcomes, but also, WHS, public health, financial, economic, and broader community and societal issues? What is best? Is it ‘home learning’, ‘off campus learning’, ‘on-line learning’, ‘face-to-face teaching’, coming to school for part of a day, all day, one day a week, every day of the week, or just for some time in between? You might ask what is the difference between these things. Furthermore, ‘experts’, politicians and educators use these terms interchangeably. It’s doubly confusing and unhelpful when you do not know the full context of the situation.
Please do not ever think that a teacher talking to a group of students by teaching face-to-face at the ‘blackboard’ for 30 minutes, or giving two hours of Maths worksheets, or allocating ten pages of an English text book is necessarily quality teaching or what is best for them at this time. These things may be useful and certainly have their place and purpose according to context, but often they are lazy teaching strategies, and do not align with the research that describes what excellent teaching and learning looks like. It’s confusing and most unhelpful when we read that this is what schools should be doing during these days of COVID-19. Please do not believe a politician who thinks that he or she knows what is best for student learning.